Thursday, June 14th 2012
Reviews: The Smashing Pumpkins
The Smashing Pumpkins Start Over with ‘Oceania’
The last fifteen years have been hard on Smashing Pumpkins fans. After the original band dissolved, Corgan eventually rejoined with drummer Jimmy Chamberlin in 2007 for the poorly received Zeitgeist, a collection of decent riffs and ideas that ultimately suffered due to muddy production and a lack of truly strong songs.
Five years (and few terrible tracks) later, Corgan remains the sole original Pumpkin. It’s certainly been a long time coming, but with Oceania, Corgan and his new Smashing Pumpkins have finally created a collection of songs worth listening to.
Quasar is a hell of a way to open a record, starting with a drumroll that instantly brings Cherub Rock to mind before the track evolves into something else entirely. Brutal drums and a frenzied, hypnotic bass line fill out the back end of the track while the guitar work sizzles in the forefront, giving the album it’s first major high point.
The Celestials opens with just an acoustic guitar, Billy’s voice and some synth orchestral lines, offering a nice change of pace from the first few tracks. Eventually the song becomes pretty power ballad-esque, filled with heavy, double-tracked guitar riffs and backing vocals by bassist Nicole Fiorentino before finally coming to a close in a sea of feedback.
The album has its share of imperfections, particularly the synth-driven One Diamond, One Heart which almost pushes the band into synthpop territory. Album closer Wildflower is another sore point, drenched with sticky orchestral strings and too closely resembling the track Pomp And Circumstances from 2007′s Zeitgeist. Luckily, these two tracks are really the only places the album’s quality really seems to suffer.
The 9-minute epic Oceania is one of the album’s best moments, a sort-of journey through most of the musical styles present on the record. The track opens with a spacey synth line and shimmering guitars before the song transitions into an short acoustic section. Mike Byrne’s drums take over seguing into a long string of floaty synth work and some gorgeous guitar solos by both Corgan and Jeff Schroeder. For some reason the band decided to fade out at the end instead of letting the song reach a real conclusion which becomes somewhat frustrating considering how strong the track is.
The irresistible Pale Horse is another definite highlight of the record, mixing together an undeniably catchy, simple riff and a truly expansive-sounding musical atmosphere. The song, one of the softest on the album, is also perhaps the biggest indication of evolution in the Pumpkins’ sound. It’s unlike anything the band has ever done, but sounds like a true natural progression of what could (and possibly should) have come after Adore.
Everything about The Chimera hints at the ill-fated Zwan project from a decade ago, but here on Oceania it sounds just fine. It’s also one of the “happiest” sounding Pumpkins tracks that Corgan has ever released, and it does a good job of picking the energy up after the slower Pale Horse.
The spiraling guitar riffs of Glissandra and the straightforward rock of Inkless make for two of the most radio-friendly tracks on the record and might just get the Pumpkins some airplay. The former in particular seems specifically designed to worm its way into the brain of any rock fan, and would be a good jumping off point to get people back into the Pumpkins after so many missteps over the last few years.
Oceania is not the best thing the Smashing Pumpkins (in any form) have put out, but it’s a great statement by the new band. It’s officially time to drop the pitchforks and stop complaining about Corgan keeping the band name – Oceania has made it clear that he still possesses the ability to write a Pumpkins’ album, and the new band is more than capable of joining him for the ride.











Can i be the first to say THANK FUCK FOR THAT.
very good review, i totally agree. 4 star album!
agreed. also: Zwan is totally underrated.
Disagree about Zeitgeist. Lots of cool songs on that record. Bleeding The Orchid and United States were the best of the bunch.
Though I am still processing the record myself I will agree that this is the ‘happiest record’ Corgan has ever done. So far to me nothing has grabbed me and pulled me in. I’m still trying to find what you seem to see in it.
Clearly I am the minority but I have tried twice to listen to this album and just can’t make it through. Perhaps I am stuck in high school and nothing can top the first three albums, perhaps Billy has just put out so much crap music that something average now seems amazing I don’t really know. Despite my lack of love for this record, I will say this is a great f’n review.
I like roughly half of it, and it makes pretty good backround music, but some of it is still too much. More listenable than much he’s released in a while, though.
I really wanted to like this album but it does nothing for me, I get bored and start zoning out after 3 songs. It all seems very bland to me. And I liked zietgeist.
Oh well I still have Soundgarden to look forward to.
He’s still not as good a Ritchie Blackmore…….
I agree with this review. The song Glissandra would be agreat single, so would my love is winter, and the celestials. This is an album you can listen to all the way through and keep your interest. Very solid record and a return to form for sp. very happy. The song Oceania does fade out strangely what is up with that?
It’s Billy’s voice, or the way they mix it or something. It just doesn’t sit right in the songs anymore
That is a perfect explanation of what killed Zeitgeist for me. He sounded flat, bored/uninspired, and separate from the music. I haven’t listened to Oceania yet but now I am less optimistic.
Don’t be. The production and audio levels are FAR better on Oceania than Zeitgeist. There are a few times it kind of sticks out but for the most part Billy’s voice sounds like part of the song instead of something floating on the top.
Yeah I agree, 2nd time through things sound much better.
Joshua Homme riffs throughout. Quit biting QOTSA dude.
This may be the most irrelevant post, but perhaps its just a coincidence that a few songs sound very close, if not spot on, to Isis songs – Pantopticon, Oceanic, Celestial. I’ll give this one a spin, but based on the posts above my anticipation is fading fast.
What I mean above is the titles to the songs.
Finally made it through the album. Didn’t bother me as much the second time through but still not drinking the Billy Corgan Kool-Aid.
I’m sorry, but I’ve been looking forward to this review for a few days now and this was totally underwhelming. Considering the awesome interview Johnny had with Billy I was expecting a lot more. Can I request we scrap this review and let Firecloud take over on this one?
James Iha’s second solo album released a few months ago is more smashing pumpkins than this
If you don’t like Billy’s voice, then you didn’t like the Pumpkins in 1992. This review sums up my feelings on the album quite nicely, actually, though I really don’t dig The Chimera. But I agree that the strengths of this album outshine any of its weaknesses.
“Quasar is a hell of a way to open a record, starting with a drumroll that instantly brings Cherub Rock to mind before the track evolves into something else entirely.”
Cherub Rock? Reminds me more of Geek USA. Either way, it IS a great start to the album and the rest of it doesn’t disappoint either.
my expectations were pretty high because I love pumpkins and although I expected something different, I’m not disappointed. My favorite track is inkless, it infected my head – guitar solo ftw